Help please Request initial evidence!!!

[Cal]

Hi, and thanks in advance for all yor help!
Sent my concurrent AOS package on 08/08 receipts on 08/21 biometric notice 08/25, biometrics done 08/31. 09/05 RFE text and email. Received RFE paper on 09/09 Request Initial Evidence I-485

* You must provide the following information for us to make a final decision on your case.
Submit all supporting tax documentation (W2,1099, form 2555 )submitted to the Internal Revenue Service for the most recent tax year.

* Based on the document submitTed with form I 864 Affidavit of Suport for the petitioner/sponsor, the income did not meet a hundred 25% of the poverty guideline for the petitioner sponsors household size. Submit evidence of assets that meet the standards listed below or obtain joint sponsor. Assets must equal the stated difference between the petitioner household income and 125% of the poverty guideline.

* Submit a completed and signed i-130a supplemental information for spousal beneficiary from the spouse beneficiary.

I'm confused I sent the 2016 taxes with also 2015, 2014 because 2016 did not meet the 125%, but the other 2 did, also sent job letter from the sponsors employer, job contract with specification of his salary commission and bonus, and pay stubs since January - august ( 2 different jobs) showing he "already" earned the 125% required by them ( they just had to add and see the numbers). Could it be that they didn't bother to check the numbers? Because I was told they base on current income, or could it be that the 2016 tax is afecting the decision? On the letter they mention that I can provide a list of assets (which we don't have, apart from motorcycle with the of ownership valued on $8000). Should I send a copy as suplemental asset? Can't find a joint sponsor.

The last thing they ask is a comelted and signed I-130A which I just realized that I didn't send, because I did my package with the G325, which I now realized it was out by 04/27/2017, could this be the real reason of the RFE, or they are just asking for it also now just in case. The RFE is for the I485, not for the I-130 where I suspect the I130A goes... insights please....

[Yestoel92]

It doesn't matter under what form they are asking on. If they send rfe you respond with what they need or call them for clarification and respond. Even if you already sent whatever they are asking you resend.

Anyway, it seems like you might be right that they did not add up the 2 jobs. So when you send your rfe back include a short letter explaining your reasoning.

Yes, you can send proof of assets too but if I were you I wouldn't bother knowing he already makes above poverty line. I would just make sure they get my explanation that he meets the 125% and provide clear proof.

[Cal]

It doesn't matter under what form they are asking on. If they send rfe you respond with what they need or call them for clarification and respond. Even if you already sent whatever they are asking you resend.
.

Anyway, it seems like you might be right that they did not add up the 2 jobs. So when you send your rfe back include a short letter explaining your reasoning.

Yes, you can send proof of assets too but if I were you I wouldn't bother knowing he already makes above poverty line. I would just make sure they get my explanation that he meets the 125% and provide clear proof.

Thanks! I was (still am a little) on panic mode, I know is the only shot, I got to do it right, needed confirmation.

[sparrowxxx419]

Hi, and thanks in advance for all yor help!
Sent my concurrent AOS package on 08/08 receipts on 08/21 biometric notice 08/25, biometrics done 08/31. 09/05 RFE text and email. Received RFE paper on 09/09 Request Initial Evidence I-485

* You must provide the following information for us to make a final decision on your case.
Submit all supporting tax documentation (W2,1099, form 2555 )submitted to the Internal Revenue Service for the most recent tax year.

* Based on the document submitTed with form I 864 Affidavit of Suport for the petitioner/sponsor, the income did not meet a hundred 25% of the poverty guideline for the petitioner sponsors household size. Submit evidence of assets that meet the standards listed below or obtain joint sponsor. Assets must equal the stated difference between the petitioner household income and 125% of the poverty guideline.

* Submit a completed and signed i-130a supplemental information for spousal beneficiary from the spouse beneficiary.

I'm confused I sent the 2016 taxes with also 2015, 2014 because 2016 did not meet the 125%, but the other 2 did, also sent job letter from the sponsors employer, job contract with specification of his salary commission and bonus, and pay stubs since January - august ( 2 different jobs) showing he "already" earned the 125% required by them ( they just had to add and see the numbers). Could it be that they didn't bother to check the numbers? Because I was told they base on current income, or could it be that the 2016 tax is afecting the decision? On the letter they mention that I can provide a list of assets (which we don't have, apart from motorcycle with the of ownership valued on $8000). Should I send a copy as suplemental asset? Can't find a joint sponsor.

The last thing they ask is a comelted and signed I-130A which I just realized that I didn't send, because I did my package with the G325, which I now realized it was out by 04/27/2017, could this be the real reason of the RFE, or they are just asking for it also now just in case. The RFE is for the I485, not for the I-130 where I suspect the I130A goes... insights please....

Hi,
I received RFE for I-130A too. And i submitted the I-130A a week later. Am currently waiting on my EAD now.

Why didn't you just get a co-sponsor to avoid this headache. My wife earned 60,000 dollar in the year 2014,40,000 in year 2015 and didn't work enough in the year 2016 cause she was sick most of the year and she earned 15,000 so i had to get me a co-sponsor to back it all up.

Just submit what is needed and on time so your case can be processed further.

[Cal]

Hi,
I received RFE for I-130A too. And i submitted the I-130A a week later. Am currently waiting on my EAD now.

Why didn't you just get a co-sponsor to avoid this headache. My wife earned 60,000 dollar in the year 2014,40,000 in year 2015 and didn't work enough in the year 2016 cause she was sick most of the year and she earned 15,000 so i had to get me a co-sponsor to back it all up.

Just submit what is needed and on time so your case can be processed further.

Hi, how good that you already finish dealing with the RFE! I want to be over with it, and be back on track. The joint sponsor is because I didn't have one, but never thought I would need one, since my husband already earned the 125%; I read that the RFE letters are system generated so mostly the always say the same.... who knows... I'll send all his pay stubs detailing the amount already earned and the taxes, the title of the motorcycle as a backup, and the I130A. And I'll cross my fingers and pray on it....
Hope you get your EAD asap....

[sparrowxxx419]

Hi, how good that you already finish dealing with the RFE! I want to be over with it, and be back on track. The joint sponsor is because I didn't have one, but never thought I would need one, since my husband already earned the 125%; I read that the RFE letters are system generated so mostly the always say the same.... who knows... I'll send all his pay stubs detailing the amount already earned and the taxes, the title of the motorcycle as a backup, and the I130A. And I'll cross my fingers and pray on it....
Hope you get your EAD asap....

Yes,they just asked for the I-130A only. So,i guessed they were okay with the other documents and supporting documents.

Just take your time(but not all your time LoL) and give them what they need. It's fine if you semd in all his pay stubs and documents of his landed properties owned if he has any.

May God see us through. Wishing you all the best too.