Student Visa denied 214(b) not fair chance given..

[quick23]

Hello,
Yesterday I had my student visa interview and I was denied under 214(b) that means on the basis that I do not have social and economic ties, but I think I was not given fair chance to show my ties. My argument for these ties
1. Social Ties? My all family members are in my native country living with me right now and no one near lives in USA not even in any other country. What more social ties could it be there if my whole family is with me in my country?
2. Economic ties? My family business is up and running for more than 30 years and it is not a small business that is conducted by my brother and we are making 5-6 Million / annum (Local Country Currency) I know it might now sound lot but it is for local currency. So, who would leave such business and intend to immigrate to US for earning only around 1 million/annum in USA?
Aren't these suffecient ties?

My Profile:
Education: Intermediate (That is high school of USA)
Currently: Working as a junior level manager in my own family business with my brother. I started doing it because he couldn't tolerate the pressure and I had to help him with him.
TOEFL: 97
Intended Course: BBA

Now, my exact interview went like this

Me: Hi mam How are you doing?
VO: So how long have you been working and for whome?
Me: I have been working for 3 years along with my brother who runs our family business of construction materials.
VO: what is your highest degree?
Me: Intermediate (She didn't look at my transcripts though I have good grades)
VO: what Year did you graduate from High School?
Me: 2007
VO: what made you continue your education now?
Me: We are looking to expand our business and being an intermediate I find myself limited in my skills and knowledge so I decided once I pursue my BBA I will have better skills and knowledge to look after it with my brother
VO: (Again with a twisted question I believe) What were you doing from 2007 to 2009?
Me: Mam in 2007 I completed my intermediate then I have been working since 2008 till now.
VO: (Signs the letter and says) Sorry you are not eligible to travel to USA right now.
Me: Thank You Mam.


Where did I blow it? Trust me or not I want to study and come back...but what to do now? Should I re-apply? they say student should re-apply only when a significant change occurs, but there is no change it is just that I think I wasn't given a fair chance to show my ties. Should I reapply and if they ask what changed? I should say I don't think I was given a fair chance to demonstrate my ties and then explain the ties?
I am really disappointed..please let me know..
thanks..

[678olive]

Yes, you can apply again. Be ready to explain why you would to your home country. Get a letter from your parents that you would join the family business and you have n% of stake in it. Be postive and confident.

Good Luck!

[quick23]

Yes, you can apply again. Be ready to explain why you would to your home country. Get a letter from your parents that you would join the family business and you have n% of stake in it. Be postive and confident.

Good Luck!

Hello,
First of all thank you so much for responding to my question I really appreciate it mate. Actually, she never asked why would I come back or anything like that. She didn't even ask anything about the business neither. She was just concerned about my Job role. The idea of having a letter about the business and stake is I think excellent. I will surely bring it next time.
And I had this answer in my mind that I would be able to work as enterprenuer along with my brother once I complete my business degree, but she didn't ask such question and I couldn't fit it in any other answer.

Plus, the first question they would ask me now is that what is the change from the last time you applied? Should I say that I have now this letter that I did not have before? or I should simply say that I believe I wasn't given a proper chance to show my social and economic ties as my family business on big scale is here in my country for economic ties and my all family members are here as well as social ties.
Please, help me I am so tense
I hope you would further reply to my queries thanks.

[678olive]

Yes. Show them the letter first, back it up with your answer as to why you would come back. Be open and honest. By the way, which consulate did you go to for your visa interview?

Also, post your experience here.
Good Luck!

[quick23]

Yes. Show them the letter first, back it up with your answer as to why you would come back. Be open and honest. By the way, which consulate did you go to for your visa interview?

Also, post your experience here.
Good Luck!

Hello,
Thank you once again. Should I write the letter to the US Consulate of my country? or just in general something like "This is to certify that quick23 would have n% of shares in our family business on his return after completing the education" or it should be like " It is to certify to the US Consulate that quick23 would have n% of shares in our family business on his return after completing the education"

I applied in Karachi, Pakistan. and I already posted the whole experience in this thread dear. did you check? any review or feedback?

[kaka]

Dear Brother i will just Suggest you

I will Just Suggest you they are not giving any body any visa neither B1/B2 nor F1/F2 etc etc they are just earning from us.

we are spending our money to build the building of Karachi US General Consulate.

Advice wait while this building wont complete build!!

your shub chinntak

Hum samjh rhey they karachi mein consulate khul gai tou relife mileyga idhar tou ghanta mill rha hai ajj itni buddi ka visa denied kar diya kahti hai sali kay you wont come back to pakistan aur ek angreiz budha betha tha he was not issuing visa to anyboy 50 interview hoy mery samney koi visa nahi milla they are just making us fool.

[quick23]

I will Just Suggest you they are not giving any body any visa neither B1/B2 nor F1/F2 etc etc they are just earning from us.

we are spending our money to build the building of Karachi US General Consulate.

Advice wait while this building wont complete build!!

your shub chinntak

Hum samjh rhey they karachi mein consulate khul gai tou relife mileyga idhar tou ghanta mill rha hai ajj itni buddi ka visa denied kar diya kahti hai sali kay you wont come back to pakistan aur ek angreiz budha betha tha he was not issuing visa to anyboy 50 interview hoy mery samney koi visa nahi milla they are just making us fool.

With due respect I do not agree with you brother. The reason is because on the next window I saw with my eyes and heard it that 3 students one by one was granted a visa. They were put into administrative process but thats a Yes 90%. So I do not believe that they are doing this, but I believe that they misinterprate any of my response or I wasn't given a proper chance to show my social and economic ties.

[kaka]

Why asking to us

With due respect I do not agree with you brother. The reason is because on the next window I saw with my eyes and heard it that 3 students one by one was granted a visa. They were put into administrative process but thats a Yes 90%. So I do not believe that they are doing this, but I believe that they misinterprate any of my response or I wasn't given a proper chance to show my social and economic ties.

If they got visa then ask them what they did and how they got visa why teasing us here bebe??