Widow Mother's visa got rejected

[pranavjoshi007]

Hi everyone,

My mother had interview on 24th may 2012 to mumbai consulate for B2 visa in gujarati.She applied for 5 months tourist visa I am living in US since 1 year and I am on H1B visa with very good job. I sent her all the document and taught her about interview, I guess she did good but still her visa got rejected under 214(b). She is been working as teacher since last 28 years in india and she is widow, I am the only one child she has.
Here are the qustion VO asked her:
Q. Who is sposoring you?
A. My son
Q. What is your son doing?
A. He is software developer in YYYY company
Q. What is his status?
A. He is on H1B
Q. When did he go?
A. July 2011 (Actually went in May 2011 and started job, I had to visit back india just in
20 days in June 2011 due to one family emergency, then I came back to USA agian in july 2011) Q. What is your husband doing?
A. He passed away (Isn't it stupid quation because she is window that was written in DS160)
Q. How many childrens you have?
A. I only have one child.
VO said sorry your visa application is rejected then my mom said that I just want to go for tourisam purpose only. he said sorry then he asked my H1 papers, my mom give him all the papers. He just looked and said sorry your visa application is rejected. Its so sad how can she be intended immigrant while I am on non immigration status? and while she has job and
savings in india.
When should she reapply for her visa?
Should I use some diffrent approch next time?


PJoshi

[peace999]

It is not a fair system but that is how they decide.
They think a widow would like to live with her only son , so she won't come back.

Even on reapplication you can't change
the main reasons for denial; widow and only child in US.

Frankly, it will be difficult for her.

[pranavjoshi007]

I know reason is not going to change next time.
If this is how they decide to give visa then why don't they make rule that perents of only one
Child who lives in US can not apply for visitor visa. Atleast that could save our money and time.
And how can she settle here permently while she has job in India and I am in H1B a non immigration
Visa? Last time she asked for 5 months visa, will it make difference if next time she ask for lesser time like 1 month?
I know she can reapply anytime but how much time gap for reapplication would be good.
If my company files for my green card then does it make any difference on her
Visa application ?

I appreciate your reply.

Thanks
PJoshi

[zakasbanda]

You can try to apply for visa again - any time really.

May be this time - you need to show stronger ties with the homeland. Some of the things that have worked in the past for people are:

1. A letter from employer that verifies the employment and sections the vacation.
2. Bank account statements
3. Real estate documents and bank account statements
4. Completely dependent dependents

[pranavjoshi007]

Thanks,

She had all the document that you mentioned in 1 to 3 last time but VO didnt even looked at it.
What is Completely dependent dependents means?
I have relatives in UK. what if she travel to other country like UK? and come back on time. Does it improve her case ot show tie to india? or if she apply for USA visa from UK does it make any diffrence?

PJoshi

[aaydrian]

As folks have said you being an only child and being a widow worked against your mother. What may have also caused the rejection is IF your mother (mis)communicated in the interview that she wanted to spend 5 months in the US. That makes no sense since your mother is a teacher and only gets about 2-3 months vacation (unless she's a professor).

Completely dependent dependent means (if I understand the person correctly) someone who fully relies on another to survive eg a child, old parents or an invalid (someone who is physically/mentally handicapped). Zakasbanda mentioned this as it may be seen as a reason why your mother has no intention of staying in the US beyond vacation time.

Your travel history with any other country has no bearing on the outcome of a tourist visa for the US. Unless she's a citizen of the UK applying there will not make any difference.

[pranavjoshi007]

Thank you all,

She is not completly dependent on me, and I think her interview went well.

May be next time she should apply for a month or two.

Pranav

[Cthalayasingam]

pranavjoshi007 hey
did you apply again for your mom what was the out come? Please help my dad is a widower, I have a sister who was in US on tourist visa who has now gone back to her homeland. They refused the visa of my dad while my sister was in US. Now she went back then dad went for interview in 9 days. Again refused on same grounds

[Libra_14]

pranavjoshi007 hey
did you apply again for your mom what was the out come? Please help my dad is a widower, I have a sister who was in US on tourist visa who has now gone back to her homeland. They refused the visa of my dad while my sister was in US. Now she went back then dad went for interview in 9 days. Again refused on same grounds

The onus is on the applicant to prove that his/her intention is purely to visit & not to stay in USA permanently (of long term). Single parent with no other child in home country are treated as potential (legal or illegal) immigrant & hard to get visitor visa for them.

[Cthalayasingam]

He has my sister in home country but she has a US visit visa. Is there no hope for him to get a B2. Please help me understand if there are ways?

[Libra_14]

Sister holding a "visit" visa shouldn't impact your mother visa. She can say she lives with her daughter & dependent on her (not you).

[user2022]

Single parent with no other child in home country are treated as potential (legal or illegal) immigrant & hard to get visitor visa for them.

In the case where the visa applicant is 80+ and using Dropbox as Interview Waiver, where is the opportunity to show the real estate papers or other strong ties to the homeland? Do they just reject or send an RFE?

[Libra_14]

In the case where the visa applicant is 80+ and using Dropbox as Interview Waiver, where is the opportunity to show the real estate papers or other strong ties to the homeland? Do they just reject or send an RFE?

No, there is no opportunity to submit other documentary proofs, but you can mention property details by self-sponsoring the visit in DS160, can show regular income from pension/rental property etc in DS160.

Or else you can opt for in-person interview as well, to show these documents.

[user2022]

....you can mention property details by self-sponsoring the visit in DS160, can show regular income from pension/rental property etc in DS160.

.

i have filled up the ds-160 form online and no-where it required me to provide details on my income as a sponsor. I will carry my bank records, W2, etc. etc., but the application itself does not have any entry to "sponsor's finance records". Did i miss something? I have Drpobox interview on this Friday.

[Libra_14]

Have her self-sponsor her visit.